2021, vol. 9, no. 1. Nagamine H.

2021, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 210-223

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22378/2313-6197.2021-9-1.210-223

   ON THE MUTUAL RELATIONS BETWEEN THE KAZAKH
KHANATES AND THE QING AND RUSSIAN EMPIRES.
BOOK REVIEW: NODA J., ONUMA T. A COLLECTION OF DOCUMENTS
FROM THE KAZAKH SULTANS TO THE QING DYNASTY

Hiroyuki Nagamine
National Institute of Technology, Oyama College
Oyama, Japan
h_nagamine@oyama-ct.ac.jp; gamaja.yokaton.13@gmail.com

Abstract: This study, titled A Collection of Documents from the Kazakh Sultans to the Qing Dynasty, deals with 16 documents addressed from Kazakh sultans to the Qing Dynasty (and the Russian Empire/Governor-General of Siberia). These were written in the Oyirad (Mongol) language with Tod script or in the Turkic language with Arabic script from the eighteenth to nineteenth century, and come complete with text, transcription, and translation. In addition, this study includes two essays written by the authors who made use of these documents. The majority of Qing documents are preserved in a collection of the First Historical Archives (第一歴史襠案館) in Beijing. Many of these documents related to the Kazakhs have started to be published as The Collection of the Archival Documents Concerning Sino-Kazakh Relations at the Time of the Qing Dynasty (清代中哈関係襠案彙編) and so on, and to be used for historical research. Of the documents dealt with in this study, 14 are from the Manchu Language Reference Copy of Grand Council Palace Memorial (軍機処満文副奏摺) of the First Historical Archives, one is from Tsentral’nyi gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Respubliki Kazakhstan, and one is from Vneshnyaya politika Rossii XIX i nachala XX veka (Moskva: Izd-vo Nauka, t. 11–12, 1979–1980). However, most of these documents are not included in the published collection mentioned above. Therefore, this study, together with the above-mentioned collection, represents another major step in the study of these documentss.
In addition, by utilizing these documents, Takahiro Onuma clarifies that the international world order between the Qing dynasty and Kazakh nomads in Central Asia was not based on the “suzerain-dependency (Ch. zong-fan 宗藩) relationship”, which was heavily influenced by Confucianism, but rather, on the “master-slave (Mon. ejen-albatu) relationship”, which originated in Mongol nomadic society. Jin Noda, who also utilized these documents, states that the title of Kazakh sultans, which has been regarded as a product of the Qing benefit policy, was in fact a result of both the Kazakh sultans and Qing requiring the ‘title-bestowal system’ in the process of the establishment of relations. This system was gradually becoming a mere formality, partly because of the influence of Russia. These findings suggest that the Kazakh khanates were independently developing a “bilateral diplomatic policy” while mediating between the Qing and Russian empires, and they highlight the policy differences of both empires toward the Kazakh khanates. We hope that the fin­dings from this study will further advance the study of the history of the mutual relations between the Kazakh khanates and the Qing and Russian empires.

Keywords: Kazakhs, Qing dynasty, Russian empire, documents, Oyirad language with Tod script, Turkic language with Arabic script, “ejen-albatu relationship”, “bilateral diplomatic policy”

For citation: Nagamine H. On the Mutual Relations between the Kazakh Khanates and the Qing and Russian Empires. Book Review: Noda J., Onuma T. A Collection of Documents from the Kazakh Sultans to the Qing Dynasty. Zolotoordynskoe obozrenie=Golden Horde Review. 2021, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 210–223. DOI: 10.22378/2313-6197.2021-9-1.210-223

Acknowledgemnts: This paper was supported by JSPS KAKENHI; Grant Number JP19K01029.

REFERENCES

  1. Vladimirtsov, B.Ya. Obshchestvennyi stroi mongolov. Mongol’skii kochevoi feodalizm [Social Structure of the Mongols. Mongolian Nomadic Feudalism]. Leningrad: USSR Academy of Sciences, 1934. xii + 224 p. (In Russian)
  2. Ishibashi H. Shinsho no ejen: Taiso, Taisō chō wo chūshin ni [Ejen in the Early Qing Period: The Taizu and Taizong Reign]. Shinchō to higashi ajia [The Qing Dynasty and East Asia]. Tokyo: Yamakawa shuppansha, 1992, 3–16. (In Japanese)
  3. Noda J. Roshin no hazama no kazafu hān koku: Surutan to shinchō no kankei o chūshin ni [The Kazakh Khanate between the Russian and Qing Empires: Particularly the relations between the Kazakh Sultans and the Qing Dynasty]. Tōyō gakuhō [Journal of the Research Department of the Toyo Bunko]. 2005, vol. 87, no. 2, pp. 29– (In Japanese)
  4. Noda J. Shindai tō’an shiryō to chū’ō ajia shi kenkyū: Qingdai zhongha quanxi dang’an huibian no shuppan ni yosete [Qing archival documents and recent research of Central Asian history: An introduction of the Qingdai zhongha quanxi dang’an huibian]. Manzokushi kenkyū [Journal of Manchu and Qing Studies]. 2007, vol. 6, pp. 162– (InJapanese)
  5. Noda J. Roshin teikoku to kazafu hankoku [The “Kazakh Khanate”: Between Russian and Qing Empires]. Tokyo: Tokyo daigaku shuppankai, 2011. vi + 292 p. (In Japanese)
  6. Noda J. The Kazakh Khanates between the Russian and Qing Empires: Central Eurasian International Relation during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 2016. xx + 350 p.
  7. Noda J. and Onuma T. A Collection of Documents from the Kazakh Sultans to the Qing Dynasty. Tokyo: Department of Islamic Area Studies, Center for Evolving Humanities, Graduate School of Humanities and Sociology, the University of Tokyo, 2010. iii + 176 p.
  8. Onuma T. Shinchō ni yoru ōroto kaku otoku shihai no tenkai: mongoru shobu ni taisuru ‘ki’ shihai no dōnyū [Banner rule over the Mongolian tribes by the Qing Dynasty: The case of Oyirad Otoks]. Tōyō gakuhō [Journal of the Research Department of the Toyo Bunko]. 2004, v 85, no. 4, pp. 1–26. (In Japanese)
  9. Onuma T. Shinchō to kazafu yūboku seiryoku tono seijiteki kankei ni kansuru ichi kōsatsu: chū’ō ajia ni okeru ejen-albatu kankei no fuen to tenkai [The political relations between the Qing Dynasty and Kazakh Nomads: Promotion of the “ejen-albatu relationship” in Central Asia]. Ajia Afurika gengo bunka no kenkyū [Journal of Asian and African Studies]. 2006, v 72, pp. 39–63. (In Japanese)
  10. Onuma T. Shin to chū’ō ajia sōgen: yūbokumin no sekai kara teikoku no henkyō e [The Qing and the Central Asian Steppe: From the Nomadic Arena to the Imperial Frontier]. Tokyo: Tokyo daigaku shuppankai, 2014. vii + 311 p. (In Japanese)
  11. Sugiyama K. Daishin teikoku no keisei to hakkisei [The Formation of the Great Qing Empire and the Eight Banner System]. Nagoya: Nagoya daigaku shuppankai, 2015. xii + 541 + 19 p. (In Japanese)

About the author: Hiroyuki Nagamine – Master of Arts, Lecturer, Department of General Education, National Institute of Technology, Oyama College (771 Nakakuki, Oyama, Tochigi 323-0806, Japan). E-mail: h_nagamine@oyama-ct.ac.jp; gamaja.yokaton.13@gmail.com

Received  December 10, 2020   Accepted for publication  February 25, 2021
Published  Online March 29, 2021