2018, vol. 6, no. 3. Ivanov V.A.

2018, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 618-634

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22378/2313-6197.2018-6-3.618-634

   NOMADS OF THE GOLDEN HORDE IN THE PERCEPTION
OF MODERN HISTORIANS

V.A. Ivanov
Bashkir State Pedagogical University named after M.Akmulla
Ufa, Russian Federation
ivanov-sanych@inbox.ru

Abstract: Objectives: To show how modern historians perceive and interpret the history of nomads of the Golden Horde regarding whom the main sources of information are archaeological sources.
Materials of the research: This article is based on the results of a critical discourse analysis of the publications by contemporary source-study researchers. Their work expounds to some extent the history of the Mongol conquest of the nomads of Dasht-i-Kipchak and highlights their role and place in the administrative and political system of the Golden Horde (Ulus of Jochi).
Results and novelty of the research: A paradoxical situation has developed in the modern historiography of the Golden Horde. The history of the Golden Horde is studied by historians and archaeologists – representatives of two related disciplines that study the same theme, that is the history of human society. However, they study this theme using different methods and based on different sources. The absence of a mutual correlation between the results obtained and conclusions based on them leads to the fact that in parallel historical and archaeological studies of the Golden Horde, parallel images of this state are often created, often contradicting each other. This is particularly evident in the publications dedicated to the nomads of Dasht-i-Kipchak, who, firstly, became one of the first targets of the Mongol conquest in Eurasia; secondly, they also became the main population of the Golden Horde. The mechanistic reading of medieval narratives without source criticism leads to a situation in historical studies which sees the geography of the dwelling area of nomads (the Örberli, the Kuns, the Kangli) and the direction of the Mongol invasion of Dasht-i-Kipchak scattered in space. Insufficient correlation of archaeological and historical data (extracted from narratives) deprives the existing historical reconstructions of objectivity and denies the interested reader of an adequate understanding.

Keywords: Golden Horde, Dasht-i-Kipchak, nomads, archaeology, narratives, migration, correlation

For citation: Ivanov V.A. Nomads of the Golden Horde in the Perception of Modern Historians. Zolotoordynskoe obozrenie=Golden Horde Review. 2018, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 618–634. DOI: 10.22378/2313-6197.2018-6-3.618-634

REFERENCES

  1. Antonov I.V. Obrazovanie Ulusa Dzhuchi [Formation of the Ulus of Jochi]. Zolotoordynskoe nasledie. Materialy Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii «Politicheskaya i sotsial’-no-ekonomicheskaya istoriya Zolotoy Ordy (XIII–XV vv.)» [Gol­den Horde Legacy. Proceeding of the International Research Conference “Political and Social and Economic History of the Golden Horde (from the thirteenth to the fifrteenth century)”], is. 1. Kazan, Fen Publ., 2009, pp. 127–137. (In Russian)
  2. Arkheologicheskaya karta Kazakhstana [Archaeological Map of Kazakhstan]. Alma-Ata, 1960. (In Russian)
  3. Akhinzhanov S.M. Kypchaki v istorii srednevekovogo Kazakhstana [The Kypchaks in the History of Medieval Kazakhstan]. Almaty, Gylym Publ., 1995. 296 p. (In Russian)
  4. Zimoni I., Kuzembaev N. Mongol’skoe zavoevanie Desht-i Kipchaka [The Mongol Conquest of Dasht-i Kipchak]. Pavlodar–Kereku, 2014. 118 p. (In Russian)
  5. Zlygostev V.A. Subedey. Vsadnik, pokoryavshiy vselennuyu [Subedei. The Horseman Who Conquered the Universe]. Ufa, Dizayn Poligraf Servis, 2011. 396 p. (In Russian)
  6. Zolotaya Orda v istochnikakh. Tom I. Arabskie i persidskie sochineniya [The Golden Horde in Sources. Vol. 1: Arabic and Persian Sources]. Sost., vvodnaya stat’ya i komm. R.P. Khrapachevskogo. Moscow, 2003. 448 p. (In Russian)
  7. Zolotaya Orda v istochnikakh. Tom III. Kitayskie i mongol’skie istochniki [The Golden Horde in Sources. Vol. 1: Chinese and Mongol Sources]. Per., sost., vvodnaya stat’ya i komm. R.P. Khrapachevskogo. Moscow, 2009. 336 p. (In Russian)
  8. Ivanov V.A. Arkheologicheskie pamyatniki kochevnikov Tsentral’noy Azii v Vostochnoy Evrope v XIII–XIV vv. [Archaeological Monuments of Central Asian Nomads in Eastern Europe in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries]. Historical and social-educational ideas. 2016, Vol. 8, no. 4, part 2, pp. 28–33. DOI: 10.17748/2075-9908-2016-8-4/2-28-33 (In Russian)
  9. Ivanov V.A. Arkheologicheskoe istochnikovedenie kochevnikov Zolotoy Ordy ili stagnatsiya dialektiki [Archaeological Source Study of the Golden Horde Nomads or Stagnation of Dialectics]. Zolotoordynskoe obozrenie=Golden Horde Review. 2016, no. 1, pp. 182–190. (In Russian)
  10. Ivanov V.A. Gorod i step’ Ulusa Dzhuchi (Zolotoy Ordy) – istoricheskaya an-titeza [The City and Steppe of the Jochid Ulus (Golden Horde): A Historical Antithesis]. Zolotoordynskaya tsivilizatsiya [Golden Horde Civilization]. 2017, no. 10, pp. 162–167. (In Russian)
  11. Ivanov V.A., Garustovich G.N., Pilipchuk Ya.V. Srednevekovye kochevniki na granitse Evropy i Azii [Medieval Nomads on the Border of Europe and Asia]. Ufa, Bashkir State Pedagogical University Publ., 2014. 396 p. (In Russian)
  12. Ivanov V.A., Kriger V.A. Kurgany kypchakskogo vremeni na Yuzhnom Urale (XII – XIV vv.) [Kurgans of the Kypchak time in the Southern Urals (from the twelfth to the fourteenth century)]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1988. 90 p. (In Russian)
    13. Ilyushin A.M. Zapadnye i vostochnye kipchaki po materialam arkheologii [The Western and Eastern Kipchaks according to the Materials of Archaeology]. Tomsk State University’s Journal of History. 2016, no. 5 (43), pp. 15–19. DOI: 10.17223/19988613/43/3 (In Russian)
  1. Kostyukov V.P. Byla li Zolotaya Orda «Kipchakskim khanstvom»? [Whether the Golden Horde Was the “Kipchak Khanate”?]. Tyurkologicheskiy sbornik [Studia Turkologica]. 2005. Moscow, 2006, pp. 199–237. (In Russian)
  2. Kostyukov V.P. Kul’turnye transformatsii v uralo-kazakhstanskoy stepi v pervoy polovine II tys. n.e. [Cultural transformations in the Ural-Kazakh steppe in the first half of the second millennium AD]. Arkheologiya Yuzhnogo Urala. Step’ (problemy kul’tu-rogeneza) [Archaeology of the Southern Urals. Steppe (problems of culturogenesis)]. Che­lyabinsk, 2006, pp. 444–457. (In Russian)
  3. Kostyukov V.P. Ulus Shibana Zolotoy Ordy v XIII–XIV vv. [The Ulus of Shiban of the Golden Horde in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries]. Kazan, Fen Publ., 2010. 200 p. (In Russian)
  4. Kriger V.A. Pogrebeniya kypchakskogo vremeni v mogil’nikakh u s. Lebedevka [Burials of Kypchak time in cemeteries near the village of Lebedevka]. Pamyatniki kochevnikov Yuzhnogo Urala [Monuments of the Nomads of the Southern Urals]. Ufa, 1984, pp. 102–116. (In Russian)
  5. Mahmud al-Kashgari. Divan Luga tat-Turk. Perevod, predislovie i komm.
    Z.-A.M. Auezovoy. Almaty, Dayk-Press, 2005. 1288 p. (In Russian)
  6. Mirgaleev I.M. Dzhuchi – pervyy pravitel’ ulusa [Jochi: The First Ruler of the Ulus]. Zolotaya Orda v mirovoy istorii [The Golden Horde in World History]. Kazan, Sh.Marjani Institute of History of Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, 2016, pp. 72–77. (In Russian)
  7. Allsen T.T. Prelyudiya k zapadnym pokhodam: mongol’skie voennye operatsii v Volgo-Ural’skom regione v 1217–1237 godakh [Prelude to the Western Campaigns: Mongol Military Operations in the Volga-Ural Region. 1217–1237]. Stepi Evropy v epokhu sredneveko-v’ya. Zolotoordynskoe vremya [Steppes of Europe in the Middle Ages. Vol. 6: The Golden Horde Time]. Donetsk, 2008, pp. 351–362. (In Russian)
  8. Pilipchuk Ya.V. Mongol’s’ke zavoyuvannya Dasht-i-Kipchak u XІІІ st. Avtoref. diss. kand. istorichn. nauk [The Mongol Conquest of Dasht-i Kipchak in the thirteenth century. The author’s abstract of the dissertation of the candidate of historical studies]. Kyiv, 2010. (In Ukrainian)
  9. Pilipchuk Ya.V. Mongol’skoe zavoevanie kocheviy vostochnykh kipchakov [The Mongolian conquest of the eastern Kipchak steppes]. Tyurkologicheskiy sbornik. 2009–2010: Tyurkskie narody Evrazii v drevnosti i srednevekov’e [Studia Turkologica. 2009–2010: Turkic Peoples of Eurasia in Antiquity and the Middle Ages]. Moscow, Vostochnaya literatura, 2011, pp. 259–288. (In Russian)
  10. Pilipchuk Ya.V. Desht-i-Kypchak na styke tsivilizatsiy [Dasht-i Kypchak at the Crossroads of Civilizations]. Ufa, 2015. 247 p. (In Russian)
  11. Pletneva S.A. Polovtsy [The Polovtsians]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1990. 208 p. (In Russian)
  12. Timokhin D., Tishin V. Khorezm, vostochnye kipchaki i Volzhskaya Bulgariya v kontse XII – nachale XIII v. [Khwarem, the Eastern Kipchaks and Volga Bulgaria at the end of the twelfth and the beginning of the thirteenth century]. Zolotaya Orda v mirovoy istorii [The Golden Horde in World History]. Kazan, Sh.Marjani Institute of History of Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, 2016, pp. 25–41. (In Russian)
  13. Trepavlov V.V. Stepnye imperii Evrazii: mongoly i tatary [Steppe Empires of Eura­sia: The Mongols and Tatars]. Moscow, Kvadriga, 2015. 368 p. (In Russian)
  14. Khrapachevskiy R.P. Voennaya derzhava Chingiskhana [The Military State of the Chinggisids]. Moscow, OOO AST Publ.; OAO “VZOI”, 2004. 557 p. (In Russian)
  15. Khrapachevskiy R.P. Polovtsy-kuny v Volgo-Kral’skom mezhdurech’e (po dan-nym kitayskikh istochnikov) [The Polovtsians-Kuns in the Volga-Ural Interfluve (according to Chinese sources)]. Moscow, 2013. 125 p. (In Russian)
  16. Chingisiana: svod svidetel’stv sovremennikov [Chinggisiana: Collection of Testimonies of Contemporaries]. Per., sost. i komment. A. Melekhina. Moscow, Eksmo Publ., 2009. 728 p. (In Russian)
  17. Allsen T.T. Mongol Imperialism. The Policies of the Grand Qan Möngke in China, Russia, and the Islamic Lands, 1251–1259. Berkeley–Los Angeles–London, 1987. 278 p.
  18. Allsen T.T. Prelude to the Western Campaigns: Mongol Military Operations in the Volga-Ural Region. 1217–1237. Archivum Eurasiae Medii Aevi. No. 3, pp. 5–24.
  19. Biran M. The Mongol transformation: from the Steppe to Eurasian Empire. Me-dieval Encounters. 10. 1–3, pp. 339–361. Available at: http://www.history.ubc.ca /sites/default/files/documents/readings/biran_medieval_encounters_2004.pdf (last accessed 24.01.2018).
  20. Golden P.B. Cumanica IV: The Tribes of the Cuman-Qipcaqs. Archivum Eurasiae Medii Aevi. 9 (1995–1997), pp. 99–107.
  21. Golden P. The shaping of the Cuman-Qïpčaqs and their world. Studies on
    the Peoples and Cultures of the Eurasian Steppes    . Bucureşti–Brăila, 2011, pp. 303–332.
  22. Halperin Ch.J. The Tatar Yoke: The Image of the Mongols in Medieval Russia. Bloomington, Indiana, 2009. 239 p.
  23. Hudud al-Alam. The Regions of the World. A Persian Geography of 372 AH / 982 AD. Tr. and expl. by V. Minorsky. Available at: http://odnapl1yazyk.narod.ru /hududalal.htm (last accessed 20.02.2018).
  24. Jiu-Hwa L. Upshur, et al. The Golden Horde. World History. Minneapolis, 1994, pp. 371–372. Available at: http://sdaworldhistory.edublogs.org/files/2015/08/32a-Mongols-1i21j6x.pdf (last accessed 24.01.2018).
  25. Sinor D. The Mongols in the West. Journal of Asian History. Vol. 33, no. 1 (1999). Available at: deremilitari.org/2014/07/the-mongols-in-the-west/
  26. Zimonyi I. Kipchaks and the Mongol Campaigns against Eastern Europe. Kipchaki Evrazii: istoriya, yazyki, pis’mennye pamyatniki [The Kipchaks of Eurasia: History, Languages, Written Monuments]. Astana, 2013. Available at: http://edq.kz/2017/09/02 /kipchaks-and-the-mongoi-campaigns-against-eastern-europe/

About the author: Vladimir A. Ivanov – Dr. Sci. (History), Professor of the Department of National History of the Bashkir State Pedagogical University named after M. Akmulla (3a, October Revolution, Ufa 450000, Russian Federation). E-mail: ivanov-sanych@inbox.ru

Received  May 11, 2018   Accepted for publication  August 22, 2018
Published online September 29, 2018