2022, vol. 10, no. 4. Nurtazina N.D., Isakhan M.B.

2022, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 910-934

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22378/2313-6197.2022-10-4.910-934
EDN: https://elibrary.ru/SLYFKY

   DECADENCE OF THE POST-GOLDEN HORDE ERA AND THE FATE
OF RELIGION IN THE KAZAKH NOMADIC SOCIETY
OF THE 15th – EARLY 18th CENTURIES

N.D. Nurtazina 1, M.B. Isakhan 2
1 Al-Farabi Kazakh National University
Almaty, Republic of Kazakhstan
nazira.nurtazina@mail.ru
2 Nur-Mubarak Egyptian University of Islamic Culture
Almaty, Republic of Kazakhstan
alash_ordabasy@mail.ru

Abstract: Research objectives: In response to the problem of diametrically opposed views on the Islamization of Kazakh nomads, this paper aims to present a new interpre­tation of the religion`s destiny in connection with post-Golden Horde decadence.
In this regard, certain tasks must be addressed: to characterize new research trends; to substantiate the argument for the completion of Islamization under Uzbek Khan and the Muslim identity of the Kazakh Khanate; to propose a hypothesis on the religion’s crisis further in order to challenge the thesis of “Superficial Islam”.
Research materials: The research used a variety of sources. Required information is contained in Muslim authors’ works such as those of Seyfi Chelebi, Fazlallah Ibn Ruzbihan, etc., as well as several Russian-European authors’ notes. Particular attention was paid to Kazakh genealogies and folklore.
Results of the research: Serious differences in views on the time of the area’s full Islamization are revealed. An alternative point of view about the full-fledged Steppe Islamization already in 14th–early 15th centuries is justified. In general characteristics of Kazakh religion, its peculiar forms in accordance with the concept of regional Islam were not qualified as a pre-Islamic complex.
At the same time, taking into account the evidence of Islam`s weakness in the Steppe of the later era, the authors propose a new approach – studying Islam in the context of the post-Golden Horde decadence. From this perspective, the idea of a gradual weakening of tradition and an institutional disintegration of religion “after Uzbek Khan” could be admitted.

Keywords: Islamization, Kazakhs, historiography, new approaches, shejere, post- Golden Horde decadence, crisis, hypothesis

For citation: Nurtazina N.D., Isakhan M.B. Decadence of the post-Golden Horde era and the fate of religion in the Kazakh nomadic society of the 15th – early 18th centuries. Zolotoordynskoe obozrenie=Golden Horde Review. 2022, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 910–934. DOI: 10.22378/2313-6197.2022-10-4.910-934 (In Russian)

REFERENCES

  1. Abashin S.N. Bobrovnikov V.O.(comp.) Podvizhniki islama. Kul’t svjatyh i sufizm v Srednej Azii i na Kavkaze [Ascetics of Islam. The cult of Saints and Sufism in Central Asia and the Caucasus Collection of articles]. Ed.: Abashin S.N. Moscow: Oriental Literature, 2003. 336 p. (In Russian)
  2. Abuseitova M.Kh. Kazahstan i Central’naja Azija v XV–XVII vv.: istorija, politika, diplomatija [Kazakhstan and Central Asia in the XV–XVII centuries: history, politics, diplomacy]. Almaty: Dyke-Press, 1998. 268 p. (In Russian)
  3. Alekseev I.L. Institucializacija islama v imperskom prostranstve I jevoljucija sistemy upravlenija musul’manskim naseleniem central’noj Rossii [The institutionalization of Islam in the Imperial space and the evolution of the management system of the Muslim population of Central Russia]. Available at: http://idmedina.ru/books/materials
    /rmforum/1/sect1_alex.htm (In Russian)
  4. Andreev I.G. Opisanie Srednej Ordy kirgiz-kajsakov [Description of the Middle Horde of Kirghiz-Kaysaks]. St. Petersburg, 1796. 83 p. (In Russian)
  5. Atygaev N.A. Kazahskoe hanstvo v sisteme mezhdunarodnyh otnoshenij v Evrazii [Kazakh Khanate in the system of international relations in Eurasia]. Kazak bolyp kalyptaskan gasyrlar [Centuries of Kazakh formation]. Taraz: DanAi, 2015, pp. 353–365. (In Russian)
  6. Bartold V.V. Sochinenija (V 9 –ti t.) [Works (In 9 volumes)]. Vol. 1–7. Moscow, Oriental literature Publ., 1963. (In Russian)
  7. Basilov V.N. Kul’t svjatyh v islame [The Cult of Saints in Islam]. Moscow: Mysl, 1970. 144 p. (In Russian)
  8. Basilov V.N. Karmysheva J. H. Islam u kazahov (do 1917 g.) [Islam among the Kazakhs (before 1917)]. Moscow, 1997. 161 p. (In Russian)
  9. Bennigsen A. Musul’mane v SSSR [Muslims in the USSR]. Paris: YmcaPress, 1983. 90 p. (In Russian)
  10. Babalar sozi: zhuztomdyk. Volume 50. Batyrlar zhyry. “Kyrymnyn kyryk batyrs” [Heroic epic.”Forty heroes of the Crimea”]. Astana: Folio, 2008. 464 p. (In Kazakh)
  11. Bes gasyr zhyrlaydy. XV gasyrdan XX gasyrdyn bas kezin deyingi kazak akyn-zhyraularyn shygarmalary. [The Song of the Five Centuries. Works of Kazakh akyns-zhyrau XV – beginning XX centuries] Vol. 1. Compiled by M. Baydildaev, Mukhtar Magauin. Almaty: Zhazushy, 1984. 256 p. (In Kazakh)
  12. Valikhanov Ch.Ch. Sobranie sochinenij: V 5–ti t. [Collected works: In 5 volumes]. Alma-Ata, Kazakh Soviet Encyclopedia, 1984–1985. (In Russian)
  13. Veselovsky N.I. Istorija Vostoka (lekcii) [History of the East (lectures)]. Saint Petersburg, 1887. 343 p. (In Russian)
  14. Vyatkin V.L. Shejhi Dzhujbari. Hodzha Islam. V.V.Bartol’d. Turkestanskie druz’ja, ucheniki i pochitateli [Sheikhi Juybari. Khoja Islam. to V.V.Bartold. Turkestan friends, students and admirers]. Tashkent, 1927, pp. 3–20 pp. (In Russian)
  15. Georgi I.I. Opisanie vseh v rossijskom gosudarstve obitajushhih narodov, a takzhe ih zhitejskih obrjadov, ver, obyknovenij, zhilishh, odezhd i prochih dostopamjatnostej [Description of all the peoples living in the Russian state, as well as their everyday rituals, beliefs, customs, dwellings, clothes and other memorabilia]. St. Petersburg, 1776. 112 p. (In Russian)
  16. Grekov B.D., Yakubovsky A.Yu. Zolotaja Orda i ee padenie [The Golden Horde and its fall]. Moscow-Leningrad: The Academy of Sciences of the Soviet Union Publ., 1950. 479 p. (In Russian)
  17. Dulati, Mohammed Haidar. Tarih-i Rashidi (Rashidova istorija) [Tarikh-i Rashidi (Rashid’s story)]. Almaty: Sanat, 1999. 656 p. (In Russian)
  18. Zhaksylykov A.J. Obrazy, motivy i idei s religioznoj soderzhatel’nost’ju v proizvedenijah kazahskoj literatury. Tipologija, jestetika, genezis [Images, motives and ideas with religious content in the works of Kazakh literature. Typology, aesthetics, genesis]. Almaty: Kazakh University, 1999. 422 p. (In Russian)
  19. Zhandarbek Z. Jasaui zholy zhane kazak tarihy [Yasawi’s path and Kazakh history]. Almaty: El Shezhire, 2006. 256 p. (In Kazakh)
  20. Iz zhurnala puteshestvija Hristofora Bardanesa v Kirgizskuju step’ 1771 goda. Istorija Kazahstana v russkih istochnikah XVI–XX vv. IV tom. [From the journal of the journey of Christopher Bardanes to the Kyrgyz steppe in 1771 / The history of Kazakhstan in Russian sources of the XVI–XX centuries. IV vol.]. Almaty: Dayke-Press, 2007, pp. 80–194 (In Russian)
  21. Ismoilov L.E., Yuzmukhametov R.T. Status sakral’nogo prostranstva v sufizme: gora [The status of sacred space in Sufism: the Mountain]. Izvestija Irkutskogo goss.univer-ta, serija «Politologija. Religiovedenie» – Irkutsk State University Bulletins, “Political Science. Religious Studies”, 2021. volume 35, pp. 107–114. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/status-sakralnogo-prostranstva-v-sufizme-gora/viewer (In Russian)
  22. Istorija Kazahstana v zapadnyh istochnikah XII–XX vv. Tom VIII. Pervye anglijskie puteshestvenniki v Kazahskoj Stepi [History of Kazakhstan in Western sources of the XII–XX centuries. Volume VIII. The first English travelers in the Kazakh Steppe]. Ed.: Erofeeva I. Trans. from English by D.M. Kostina. Almaty: Sanat, 2006. 312 p. (In Russian)
  23. Istorija Kazahstana v russkih istochnikah XVI–XX vv. Obozrenie Kirgiz-kajsakskoj stepi. 1803 i 1804 gg. Ja.P. Gaverdovskogo. ss. 155-495. [The history of Kazakhstan in Russian sources of the XVI–XX centuries. Review of the Kirghiz-Kaysak steppe. 1803 and 1804 by Ya.P. Haverdovsky], pp. 155–495. Ed.: I.V. Erofeeva, B.T. Zhanaev. Almaty: Dyke-Press, 2007. 620 p. (In Russian)
  24. Istorija religij v 2 t. Vol.1. [History of Religions in 2 vols. Vol.1]. Ed.: I.N. Yablokov. Moscow: Vysshaja shkola Publ., 2004. 464 p. (In Russian)
  25. Izvestija anglichan o Rossii XVІ [News of the British about Russia of the XVII century]. Moscow: Imperial society of history and antiquities, 1884. 105 p. (In Russian)
  26. Izmailov I.L. Islam i jazychestvo v uluse Dzhuchi: problemy istoriografii i istochnikovedenija [Islam and Paganism in Jochi ulus: problems of historiography and source studies]. Available at: https://www.sgu.ru/archive/old.sgu.ru/files/nodes
    /9810/08.pdf (In Russian)
  27. Kazakhstan (Z. Dzhandosova). Islam na territorii byvshej Rossijskoj imperii. Jenciklopedicheskij slovar [Kazakhstan (Z. Jandosova). Islam on the territory of the former Russian Empire. Encyclopedic Dictionary]. Ed.: S.M. Prozorov. Issue 3. Mosow: “Oriental Literature” of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 2001, pp. 47–52. (In Russian)
  28. Kazahsko-russkie otnoshenija v XVI–XVIII vv. Sbornik dokumentov i materialov [Kazakh-Russian relations in the XVI–XVIII centuries. Collection of documents and materials]. Alma-Ata: Academy of Sciences Publ., 1961. 743 p. (In Russian)
  29. Kazahsko-russkie otnoshenija v XVIII–XIX vv. Sbornik dokumentov i materialov [Kazakh-Russian relations in the XVIII–XIX centuries. Collection of documents and materials]. Alma-Ata: Academy of Sciences Publ., 1964. 575 p. (In Russian)
  30. Karutc R. Sredi kirgizov i turkmen na Mangyshlake [Among the Kyrgyz and Turkmens in Mangyshlak]. St. Petersburg, 1910. 136 p. (In Russian)
  31. Kobishhanov Ju.M. Istorija rasprostranenija islama v Afrike [The history of the spread of Islam in Africa]. Moscow: Nauka, 1989. 223 p. (In Russian)
  32. Kobishhanov Ju.M. Imperija Dzhuchidov. Ocherki istorii rasprostranenija islamskoj civilizacii [The Empire of the Juchids. Essays on the history of the spread of Islamic civilization]. Vol. 2. Moscow, ROSSPEN, 2002. pp. 13-130. (In Russian)
  33. Kradin N.N. Kochevniki Evrazii [Nomads of Eurasia]. Almaty: Dyke-press, 2007. 416 p. (In Russian)
  34. Kusainov Sh.K. Agiografija v kazahskom fol’klore [Hagiography in Kazakh folklore]: Dis. candidate of Philological sciences. Almaty, 2004. 148 p. (In Russian)
  35. Karibaev B.B. Kazak khandygynyn kurylu tarihy [Formation of the Kazakh Khanate]. Almaty: Sardar Publ. house, 2014. 520 p. (In Kazakh)
  36. Kabyshuly, I. Kazak kauymy. Kazak ulysynyn 2200-zhyldyk tarikhy [Kazakh Community. The 2200-year history of the Kazakh ulus]. Almaty: Zhazushy, 1997. 224 p. (In Kazakh)
  37. Kudaiberdiuly Sh. Shygarmalary [Essays]. II vol. Almaty: Zhibek, 2007. 624 p. (In Kazakh)
  38. Kurbanali Khalid. Tauarih hamsa (Bes tarikh) [History/Tavarih] / Ed. B.Tot’enaev, A. Zholdasov. Almaty: Demeu, 1992. 146 p. (In Kazakh)
  39. Levshin A.I. Opisanie kirgiz-kazach’ih i kirgiz-kajsackih ord i stepej [Description of Kirghiz-Cossack and Kirghiz-Kaysak hordes and steppes]. Almaty: Sanat, 1996. 656 p. (In Russian)
  40. Magauin, M.M. Kobyz i kop’e: Povestvovanie o kazahskih akynah i zhyrau XV–XVIII v. [Kobyz and the spear: A narrative about the Kazakh akyns and Zhyrau of the XV-XVIII century]. Trans. from Kazakh by P. Kosenko. Alma-Ata: Zhazushy, 1970. 160 p. (In Kazakh)
  41. Mendikulov M.M. Pamjatniki narodnogo zodchestva Zapadnogo Kazahstana [Monuments of folk architecture of Western Kazakhstan]. Alma-Ata: Oner, 1987. 156 p. (InRussian)
  42. Muminov A.K. Kazahskie hodzhi [Kazakh khojas]. Shygys – East, 2004, no. 1, pp. 229–235. (In Russian)
  43. Mustafina R.M. Bytovoj islam u kazahov (XIX–XX vv.) (istoriko-etnogra­ficheskoe issledovanie) [Everyday Islam among the Kazakhs (XIX–XX centuries) (historical and ethnographic research)]. Doctoral dis. of hist. sciences. Almaty, 2006. 309 p. (In Russian)
  44. Mynzhan Nygmet. Kazaktyn kyskasha tarikhy [A brief history of the Kazakhs]. Ürümqi, Shynzhan Publ. house, 1987. Reprint: Almaty, Zhalyn, 1999. 400 p. (In Kazakh)
  45. Nurgalieva A.M. Ocherki po istorii islama v Kazahstane [Essays on the history of Islam in Kazakhstan]. Almaty: Dyke-Press, 2005. 224 p. (In Russian)
  46. Nurtazina N.D. Rasprostranenie islama i formirovanie kazahskoj musul’manskoj tradicii [The spread of Islam and the formation of the Kazakh Muslim tradition]. Almaty: Kazakh University, 2016. 354 p. (In Russian)
  47. Prozorov S.M. Novyj metodologicheskij podhod k izucheniju islama v Rossii [A new methodological approach to the study of Islam in Russia]. / Islam kak ideologicheskaja sistema [Islam as an ideological system]. Moscow: Oriental Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 2004. pp. 378–380. (In Russian)
  48. Proshloe Kazahstana v istochnikah i materialah: Sbornik [The past of Kazakhstan in sources and materials: Collection]. Ed.: S.D. Asfendiyarov and P.A. Kunte. Alma-Ata, 1935. Reprint: Almaty: Kazakhstan, 1997. 383 p. (In Russian)
  49. Radlov V.V. Obrazcy narodnoj literatury tjurkskih plemen Ch. 3. [Samples of folk literature of Turkic tribes. Part 3]. St. Petersburg, 1870. 712 p. (In Russian)
  50. Rakushin A.I. Stanovlenie gosudarstvennoj religii Zolotoj Ordy i islamizacija kochevyh tjurkskih jetnosov Nizhnego Povolzh’ja v XIII–XV vekah [Formation of the state religion of the Golden Horde and Islamization of nomadic Turkic ethnic groups of the Lower Volga region in the XIII–XV centuries] Available at: http://www.seun.ru
    /books/Books/Kafistorii/Metod/SarPov200/Rakushin.htm (In Russian)
  51. Mustafina R.M. Religioznye verovanija. Islam v XIV–XV vv. Rasprostranenie islama. [Religious beliefs. Islam in the XIV–XV centuries. The spread of Islam]. Istorija Kazahstana (s drevnejshih vremen do nashih dnej.V pjati tomah. Vol. 2. – The history of Kazakhstan (from ancient times to the present day. In five volumes. Vol. 2. Almaty: Atamura, 2010. pp. 239–245, pp. 581–585. (In Russian)
  52. Rychkov P.I. Istorija Orenburgskaja (1730–1750) [History of Orenburg (1730-1750)]. Orenburg: Orenburg. Governorship Statistical Committee Publ., 1896. 95 p. (In Russian)
  53. Tiesenhausen V.G. Sbornik materialov, otnosjashhihsja k istorii Zolotoj Ordy T. 1. [Collection of materials related to the history of the Golden Horde T. 1]. St. Petersburg, G. Stroganov’s Publ., 1884. 563 p. (In Russian)
  54. Sbornik materialov, otnosjashhihsja k istorii Zolotoj Ordy. Vol. II. Izvlechenija iz persidskih sochinenij, sobrannye V.G. Tizengauzenom i obrabotannye A.A. Romas­kevichem i C.L. Volinym [Collection of materials related to the history of the Golden Horde. Vol. II. Extracts from Persian works collected by V.G. Tizengauzen and processed by A.A. Romaskevich and C.L. Volin]. Moscow-Leningrad: Academy of Sciences of USSR Press, 1941. 308 p. (In Russian)
  55. Sultangalieva A.K. Islam v Kazahstane: istorija, jetnichnost’ i obshhestvo [Islam in Kazakhstan: history, ethnicity and society]. Almaty: Kazakhstan Institute of Strategical Research under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan, 1998. 188 p. (In Russian)
  56. Sultanov T.I. Podnjatye na beloj koshme. Potomki Chingis-hana [Raised on a white felt carpet]. Descendants of Chingis Khan. Almaty: Dyke Press, 2001. 276 p. (In Russian)
  57. Toleubaev A.T. Relikty doislamskih verovanij v semejnoj obrjadnosti kazahov [Relics of pre-Islamic beliefs in Kazakh family rituals]. Alma-Ata: Gylym, 1991. 213 p. (InRussian)
  58. Trepavlov V.V. Istorija Nogajskoj Ordy [History of the Nogai Horde]. Moscow, Oriental Literature of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 2001. 752 p. (In Russian)
  59. Trepavlov V.V. Eastern and northern limits of the Nogai Horde in the XVI–XVI centuries. Available at: https://elar.urfu.ru/bitstream/10995/2822/3/pristr-05-14.pdf . (In Russian)
  60. Ulrich Rudolf. Al-Maturidi i sunnitskaja teologija v Samarkande [Al-Maturidi and Sunni theology in Samarkand]. Almaty: Foundation “XXI vek”, 1998. 286 p. (In Russian)
  61. Utemish hadji. Chingiz name [Chingis nameh]. Alma-Ata: Gylym, 1992. 243 p. (In Russian)
  62. Fazlallah ibn Ruzbihan Isfahani. Mihman-name–ji Buhara [Mikhman-name–yi Bukhara]. From Persian. Moscow: Nauka, 1976. 197 p. (In Russian)
  63. Fedorov-Davydov G.A. Kochevniki Vostochnoj Evropy pod vlast’ju zolotoordynskih hanov [Nomads of Eastern Europe under the rule of the Golden Horde Khans]. Moscow: Moscow University Publ., 1966. 276 p. (In Russian)
  64. Cinskaja imperija i kazahskie hanstva (vtoraja polovina XVIII – pervaja tret’ XIX vv.). Ch. 2. [The Qing Empire and the Kazakh khanates (the second half of the XVIII – the first third of the XIX centuries). Part 2]. Alma-Ata: Nauka, 1989. 227 p. (In Russian)
  65. Shakarim Kudajberdy-uly. Rodoslovnaja tjurkov, kirgizov, kazahov i hanskih dinastij [The genealogy of the Turks, Kirghiz, Kazakhs and Khan dynasties]. from Kazakh. Alma-Ata: Dastan, 1990. 120 p. (In Russian)
  66. Judin V.P. «Zija al kulub» Muhammada Avaza o kazahah XVI v. [Izvestia “Ziya al kulub” by Muhammad Avaz about the Kazakhs of the XVI century]. Vestnik AN Kaz SSR – Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the Kazakh SSR, 1966, no. 5, pp. 71–76. (InRussian)
  67. Junusova A.B. Islam v Bashkortostane [Islam in Bashkortostan]. Ufa: Ufa Polygraph Combine, 1999. 352 p. (In Russian)
  68. Defterdâr Seyfı Çelebı Türkıstan ve uzak doğu seyahatnâmesı [Defterdâr Seyfı Çelebi’s notes of Turkestand and Far East]. : S. Acar. Istanbul, Selenge Yayınları, 2014. 158 p. (In Turkish)
  69. DeWeese D. Islamization and native religion in the Golden Horde. Baba Turkles and conversion to Islam in historical and epic tradition. University Park Pennsylvania State Univ. Press. 1994. 638 p.
  70. Hādī Muḥammad Ṭālib Ibn-Ḥaḍrat Tāǧ-ad-Dīn Ḥasan Ḫwāǧa al-Ḥusainī: Maṭlab aṭ-ṭālibīn, 1237[1821]. Manuscript of the Berlin State Library. Available at: https://digital.staatsbibliothek-berlin.de/werkansicht/?PPN=PPN848539966 (In Persian).
  71. Islam in Modern History. By Wilfred Cantwell Smith. New-York: Princeton University Press, 1957. 326 p.
  72. Frank, Allen. Muslim Religious Institutions in Imperial Russia. The Islamic World of Novouzensk District &the Kazakh Inner Horde, 1780–1910. Leiden, Boston, Koln: Brill, 2001. 147 p.

About the authors: Nazira D. Nurtazina – Dr. Sci. (History), Associate Professor of the Department of the History of Kazakhstan, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University (71, Al-Farabi Ave., Almaty 050040, Republic of Kazakhstan). E-mail: nazira.nurtazina@mail.ru

Mukhan B. Isakhan – Ph.D. (Religious Studies), Lecturer of the Department of Religious Studies, Nur-Mubarak Egyptian University of Islamic Culture (73, Al-Farabi Ave., Almaty 050060, Republic of Kazakhstan). E-mail: alash_ordabasy@mail.ru

Received   May 20, 2022   Accepted for publication August 10, 2022
Published   Online December 29, 2022