2017. Vol. 5, no. 3. Mirko Sardelić
2017. Vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 494-508
Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts
The research objective is to analyse why the accounts of two missionaries who visited the same Mongol “Other” in 1245 are quite different, despite their authors belonging to the same Christian circle. More specifically, the paper explores why Simon’s report is so much more negative in its depiction of the Mongols, and the imagological and emotional impact that these representations had.
My research materials include the two mendicant reports produced by John and Simon as well as extant scholarly discussions of various aspects of the Mongol Other, apocalyptic literature, and the relations between Western Christendom and the Mongol Empire in the mid-13th century.
The research innovation of the article is in the comparison of the two contemporary accounts, the elaboration of their differences in representation of the Mongols, and the analysis of their imagery from the perspective of the history of emotions.
The aim of this paper is to show that in interpreting medieval European texts about the Mongols, one should combine approaches from various fields, including (but not limited to) history of emotions, cultural and literal history, anthropology, cross-cultural sociology, and others. Immediate and incorrect interpretations that the Mongols were cannibals or sodomites, as one could be tempted to hold from the account of Simon of Saint-Quentin, must be moderated from scholarly perspectives. These interpretations were the result of sediment layers of events in the 1240s: the violent contact of the Mongol armies with Western Christendom, contemporary Christian attempts to put the newcomers into known apocalyptic frameworks, and most probably the personal trauma of the author who had been threatened with death after an inaction with the Mongols, might be explained both as a cross-cultural misunderstanding and a display of power.
Research results: Comparison of the two accounts, one written by John of Plano Carpini and the other by Simon of Saint-Quentin, the contextualization of these sources within 13th-century missionary literature, parallel analysis of the imagery, as well as reference to other contemporary texts on the Mongols, offer a sound starting point for a complex process of re-creating the imagined Mongol conceived by Europeans in the late Middle Ages. This imagined Mongol consists of hundreds of reused images ranging from the Classical antiquity and biblical texts to medieval prophecies, with a power to elicit the most powerful emotions by a single reference. Subtle interdisciplinary approach is always needed to avoid misinterpretations of often highly emotional images that can bring hope or sow hatred, depending on their (mis)use.
Keywords: John of Plano Carpini, Simon of Saint-Quentin, mendicants, early papal missions to the East, 13th-century Mongol imaginary, apocalyptic literature, history of emotions
For citation: Sardelić M. John of Plano Carpini vs Simon of Saint-Quentin: 13th-century Emotions in the Eurasian Steppe. Zolotoordynskoe obozrenie=Golden Horde Review. 2017. Vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 494–508. DOI: 10.22378/2313-6197.2017-5-3.494-508
- Arens W. The Man-Eating Myth: Anthropology and Anthropophagy. Oxford University Press, 1979. xii + 206 p.
- Carpini J.P. Ystoria Tartarorum, trans. anonymous nun of Stanbrook Abbey. C. Dawson (ed.), The Mission to Asia: Narratives and Letters of the Franciscan Missionaries in Mongolia and China in the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries. London, Sheed and Ward, 1955, pp. 3‒72.
- Chapman H.A., Anderson A.K. Understanding disgust. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1251, 1 (2012), pp. 62‒76.
- Collins J.J. Introduction: Towards the Morphology of a Genre. Semeia 14 (1979): Apocalypse: The Morphology of a Genre, pp. 1‒20.
- Collins J.J. The Apocalyptic Imagination. An introduction to Jewish Apocalyptic Literature, 2nd ed., Grand Rapids/Cambridge, 1997. viii + 280 p.
- Connell C.W. Western Views of the Origin of the Tartars: An Example of the Influence of Myth in the Second Half of the 13th Century. Journal of Medieval and Renaissance Studies, vol. 3, no. 1 (1973), pp. 115‒137.
- DeWeese D.A. The influence of the Mongols on the religious consciousness of 13th century Europe. Mongolian Studies, V (1978‒9), pp. 41‒78.
- Giffney N. ‘The Age is Drowned in Blood’: Western Propaganda and the Mongol Invasion of Eastern Europe, 1236–56. The History Review 12 (2002), pp. 188‒193.
- Giffney N. Monstrous Mongols. Postmedieval: a journal of medieval cultural studies, 3 (2012), pp. 227‒245.
- Guzman G.G. Simon of Saint-Quentin and the Dominican Mission to the Mongol Baiju: A Reappraisal. Speculum, vol. 46, no. 2 (Apr., 1971), pp. 232‒249.
- Guzman G.G. The Encyclopedist Vincent of Beauvais and His Mongol Extracts from John of Plano Carpini and Simon of Saint-Quentin. Speculum, vol. 49, no. 2 (Apr., 1974), pp. 287‒307.
- Guzman G.G. Reports of Mongol Cannibalism in the Thirteenth-Century Latin Sources: Oriental Fact or Western Fiction? S.D. Westrem (ed.), Discovering New Worlds: Essays on Medieval Exploration and Imagination, Garland, 1991, pp. 31–68.
- Guzman G.G. European clerical envoys to the Mongols: Reports of Western merchants in Eastern Europe and Central Asia, 1231–1255. Journal of Medieval History, 22,1 (1996), pp. 53‒67.
- Hautala R. Early Latin Reports about the Mongols (1221): Reasons for Distortion of Reality. Zolotoordynskoe obozrenie=Golden Horde Review. 2015, no. 1, pp. 50‒67.
- Hautala R. Early Hungarian Information on the Beginning of the Western Campaign of Batu (1235–1242). Acta Orientalia Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae, 69, 2 (2016), pp. 183‒199.
- Jackson P. William of Rubruck: A Review Article. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland, no. 1 (1987), pp. 92‒97.
- Jackson P. The crusade against the Mongols (1241). Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 42 (1991), pp. 1‒18.
- Jackson P. Early missions to the Mongols: Carpini and his contemporaries. The Hakluyt Society Annual Report for 1994, pp. 14‒32.
- Jackson P. Medieval Christendom’s encounter with the alien. Historical Research, vol. 74 (2001), pp. 347‒369.
- Jackson P. The Mongols and the West, 1221‒1410, Pearson, 2005. xxxiv + 414 p.
- Yazykov D. Sobranie puteshestviy k tataram i drugim vostochnym narodam, v XIII, XIV i XV stoletiyakh [Collection of Travels to the Tatars and Other Eastern Peoples in the 13th, 14th and 15th centuries]. St. Petersburg, 1825. (In Russian)
- Jones W.R. The Image of the Barbarian in Medieval Europe. Comparative Studies in Society and History, vol. 13, no. 4 (Oct., 1971), pp. 376‒407.
- Kappler C. L’image des Mongols dans le Speculum historiale de Vincent de Beauvais. S. Lusignan, M. Paulmier-Foucart & A. Nadeau (eds.), Vincent de Beauvais. Intentions et réceptions d’une oeuvre encyclopédique au Moyen-Âge. Saint-Laurent/Paris (Cahiers d’études médiévales. Cahier spécial 4), 1990, pp. 219‒240. (In French)
- Klopprogge A. Ursprung und Ausprigung des abendlindischen Mongolenbildes im 13. Jahrhundert: Ein Versuch zur Ideengeschichte des Mittelalters. Wiesbaden, Harrassowitz, 1993. xi + 277 p. (In German)
- Klopprogge A. Das Mongolenbild im Abendland. S. Conermann, J. Kusber (eds.), Die Mongolen in Asien und Europa. Frankfurt, Peter Lang, 1997. (In German)
- McGinn B. Visions of the End: Apocalyptic Traditions in the Middle Ages. New York, Columbia University Press, 1979. xxvii + 390 p.
- Pelliot P. Les Mongols et la papauté. Revue de l’Orient Chrétien. 3e série, t. III (XXIII), nos. 1 et 2 (1922‒23), pp. 3‒30; t. IV (XXIV), nos. 3 et 4 (1924), pp. 225‒335; t. VIII (XXVIII), nos. 1 et 2 (1931‒32), pp. 3‒84. (In French)
- Phaire B. R. Papal Motivations for an Asian Apostolate (1245–1254): An Analysis. PhD Dissertation at New York University, 1972. 96 leaves.
- Phillips K. Before Orientalism. Asian Peoples and Cultures in European Travel Writing, 1245–1510, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2013. viii + 314 p.
- Rachewiltz I. Papal Envoys to the Great Khans. London, Faber & Faber, 1971. 230 p.
- Richard J. Simon de Saint-Quentin. Histoire des Tartares. Paris, 1965. 129 p. (In French, Latin)
- Richard J. La Papauté et les Missions d’Orient au Moyen Age (13e–15e siècles). Rome, École Française de Rome, 1977. xxxiv + 325 p. (In French)
- Rubruck W. The Mission of Friar William of Rubruck. His Journey to the Court of the Great Khan Möngke 1253–1255, transl. by P. Jackson, notes by P. Jackson and D. Morgan. London, The Hakluyt Society, 1990.
- Ruotsala A. Europeans and Mongols in the Middle of the Thirteenth Century: Encountering the Other, Helsinki, Finnish Academy of Sciences, 2001. 333 p.
- Salimbene de Adam. Cronica fratris Salimbene de Adam. MGH Scriptores XXXII, O. Holder-Egger (ed.). Hannover, Leipzig, 1905–1913. (In Latin)
- Sardelić M. The Mongols and Europe in the First Half of the 13th Century: Prophecies and Apocalyptic Scenarios. A.R. Andrews (ed.). Proceedings of the conference Prophecy, Divination, Apocalypse: 33rd Annual Medieval and Renaissance Forum, 2013, pp. 100‒112.
- Saunders J.J. Matthew Paris and the Mongols. Essays in Medieval History presented to Bertie Wilkinson. T.A. Sandquist and M. R. Powicke (eds.). Toronto, University of Toronto Press, 1969, pp. 116‒132.
- Schmieder F. Europa und die Fremden. Die Mongolen im Urteil des Abendlandes vom 13. bis in das 15. Jahrhundert. Sigmaringen, Thorbecke, 1994. 396 p. (In German)
- Schmieder F. Nota sectam maometicam atterendam a tartaris et christianis: The Mongols as non-believing apocalyptic friends around the year 1260. Journal of Millenial Studies, vol. 1, no. 1 (Spring 1998), pp. 1‒11.
- Schmieder F. Cum hora undecima: The Incorporation of Asia into the Orbis Christianus. G. Armstrong & I. Wood (eds.). Christianizing Peoples and Converting Individuals. Turnhout, 2000, pp. 259‒265.
- Schmieder F. Christians, Jews, Muslims – and Mongols: Fitting a Foreign People into the Western Christian Apocalyptic Scenario. Medieval Encounters12,2 (2006), pp. 274‒295.
- Sinor D. John of Plano Carpini’s return from the Mongols: new light from a Luxemburg manuscript. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, 1957, pp. 193‒206.
- Sinor D. Foreigner-Barbarian-Monster. East-West in Art: Patterns of Culture and Aesthetic Relationships. T. Bowie (ed.). Bloomington, IN, Indiana University Press, 1966, pp. 136‒153.
- Vincentius Bellovacensis (Vincent de Beauveais). Speculum Historiale. Biblioteca Mundi seu Speculi Maioris, tomus IV. Duaci, ex officina typographica Baltazaris Belleri, 1624. (In Latin)
- Von den Brincken A.-D. Die Mongolen im Weltbild der Lateiner um die Mitte des 13. Jahrhunderts unter besonderer Berücksichtigung des ‘Speculum Historiale‘ des Vincenz von Beauvais OP. Archiv für Kulturgeschichte 57 (1975), pp. 117‒140. (In German)
- Vuorinen M. Introduction: Enemy Images as Inversions of the Self. Enemy Images in War Propaganda. M. Vuorinen (ed.). Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2012.
About the author: Mirko Sardelić – Ph.D. (Medieval History), Research Associate at the Department for Historical Research of the Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts; Co-Director of the Centre for the Study of Emotions in Cross-Cultural Exchange (Strossmayerov trg 2, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia); Honorary Research Fellow of the ARC Centre of Excellence for the History of Emotions (Europe 1100–1800) at University of Western Australia. E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Received May 19, 2017 Accepted for publication August 31, 2017
Published online September 30, 2017